Missile test in Iran violated U.N. ban: expert panel
The IAEA also decided on Tuesday to close its investigation into whether Iran once had a nuclear weapons program
The Emad rocket that Iran tested on Oct. 10 was a ballistic missile capable of delivering a nuclear warhead, which makes it a violation of a United Nations Security Council resolution, a team of sanctions monitors said in a confidential new report.
“On the basis of its analysis and findings the Panel concludes that Emad launch is a violation by Iran of paragraph 9 of Security Council resolution 1929,” the council’s Panel of Experts on Iran said in its report.
Reuters on Tuesday reviewed the 10-page report, which was dated Dec. 11 and went to members of the Security Council’s Iran sanctions committee in recent days.
IAEA decides to close nuke probe
Meanwhile, the U.N. nuclear watchdog’s 35-nation board decided on Tuesday to close its investigation into whether Iran once had a nuclear weapons program, opting to support Tehran’s deal with major powers rather than dwell on its past activities.
In a symbolic victory for Iran, the International Atomic Energy Agency’s Board of Governors passed a resolution that would end its long-running inquiry but allows inspectors to continue to police the country’s nuclear program.
“Done,” a diplomat in the closed-door IAEA board meeting said by text message, adding that the decision was reached by consensus, meaning the resolution was unopposed. Other diplomats confirmed the outcome of the session.
The IAEA produced a report this month that strongly suggested Iran had a secret nuclear weapons program up until 2003, though it found no sign of weapons-related activities beyond 2009.
Despite the finding -- the clearest indication yet by the IAEA, after 12 years of investigation, that Iran was trying to develop an atom bomb even though it denies that accusation -- the international response to the report has been muted.
The United States, Russia, Britain, France, Germany and China reached a deal with Tehran in July under which sanctions weighing on Iran's economy will be lifted in exchange for restrictions on the Islamic Republic's atomic activities.
Those six powers want to press ahead with implementing the July deal and hoped that the IAEA report, produced under the deal, would draw a line under the long-disputed issue of so-called “possible military dimensions” to Iran’s activities.
Supporters of the July deal argue that it gives the IAEA far more intrusive powers to inspect Iran’s facilities and to monitor what it is doing, and that it extends the time Tehran would need to build an atom bomb if it chose to do so.
“As we close out this important chapter here today, we must remain mindful that we are not closing the agency’s ability to investigate any potential concerns that may arise,” U.S. envoy Henry Ensher said in the text of his speech to the board.
With companies from the six powers and other nations lining up to do business in the Islamic Republic once sanctions are lifted, there had been little opposition to the resolution.
Beyond the IAEA board, however, some have argued that a full examination of Iran’s past violations of its nuclear no-proliferation obligations has been sacrificed for the sake of the political agreement reached in Vienna in July.
“Iran’s cooperation was certainly not sufficient to close the overall PMD file,” said the Washington-based Institute for Science and Technology, which follows the Iran case closely.
Tuesday’s board resolution provides for the heading under which Iran was being investigated to be closed once Iran puts in place the restrictions on its nuclear activities called for by the July deal, which Iran expects to have done by January.
The resolution also asks the IAEA’s chief to report to the Board of Governors and the U.N. Security Council “at any time if the Director General has reasonable grounds to believe there is an issue of concern.”
Israel on Tuesday warned “serious doubts” still surround Iran’s nuclear program.
“The IAEA report clearly indicates once again that Iran has conducted a coordinated effort to develop a nuclear explosive device, including activities taking place after 2003,” the Israeli foreign ministry said.
“For over a decade, Iran has been non-cooperative and deceptive,” a ministry statement read. “Serious doubts and outstanding issues regarding Iran’s program still remain.”
“Iran is still required to cooperate fully and in a satisfying manner with the agency in order to resolve all outstanding issues and verify the peaceful nature of Iran’s program,” it added.
- U.S. to raise Iran missile test at U.N.: State Department
- France says Iran missile test ‘worrying’ violation of U.N. resolution
- U.S. envoy says Iran tested nuclear-capable missile, violating U.N.
- Iran tests missile, ‘breaches U.N. resolutions’
- U.S. conducting ‘serious review’ of Iran missile test
- Iran’s long aim for its ballistic missiles
- Missile test in Iran violated U.N. ban: expert panel