Lyft shares soar on Nasdaq debut, setting stage for Uber

Lyft Inc’s shares rose as much as 23 percent in their market debut on Friday, amid strong investor demand for the ride-hailing service that bodes well for larger rival Uber Technologies Inc.

Lyft’s IPO, which is the year’s biggest thus far, sets the stage for other Silicon Valley unicorns seeking to debut in the stock market this year, including Pinterest Inc, Postmates Inc and Slack Technologies Inc.

The success of the IPO came despite Lyft’s steep loses, criticism of its dual-class share structure, and some concerns over its strategy for autonomous driving and new laws aimed at increasing driver pay.

Public market investors, keen on Lyft’s revenue growth and after enduring a long stretch with few IPOs from highly valued tech companies, piled into the offering.

“There’s money that wants to be invested into tech. This is a new area and people are definitely interested in exploring it,” said Catherine McCarthy, an Allianz research analyst.

On Thursday, Lyft priced 32.5 million shares, slightly more than it was offering originally, at $72, the top of its already elevated $70-$72 per share target range, raising $2.34 billion in its initial public offering.

The stock opened at $87.24 but later pared gains to close up 8.7 percent at $78.29, giving Lyft a market capitalization of around $22.2 billion.

Lyft’s offering ended up 20 times oversubscribed, similar to other high-profile IPOs, with more than 500 orders from institutional investors such as mutual funds, according to people familiar with the matter.

Despite the optimism, there are also mounting concerns that these tech IPOs may be coming at the peak of the market, when the benchmark S&P 500 Index has risen more than 200 percent since 2008. 

Loss-making ‘Unicorns’ 

Lyft’s 2018 loss widened to $911 million from $688 million in 2017, despite revenue doubling in 2018 to $2.16 billion. The company has not laid out a timeline for when it will turn a profit.

As a result, the IPOs of Lyft and other loss-making unicorns present a predicament for investors sitting on the fence - they do not want to miss out on popular companies with fast growth, but must weigh the risks of businesses with unproven economics.

“Every portfolio manager is going to have to make a decision in the next 12 to 18 months about these new IPOs. It’s a growing part of the market,” said JMP Securities President Mark Lehmann.

Uber, which is also loss-making, would be valued at about $128 billion at its IPO if awarded the same multiple as Lyft. Uber is planning to launch its IPO in April, sources have said.

Some of the companies’ losses come from subsidizing rides, a tactic to attract riders with discounts.

“With Uber and Lyft becoming public companies, shareholders will expect them to rationalize prices on rides towards sustainable levels,” said Paul Hudson, founding partner at Glade Brook Capital Partners.

Lyft, as of December, had 39 percent market share in the United States, up from 35 percent early last year.

Its success in battling better-funded Uber for market share surprised even its own investors.

“Nobody knew they (Lyft) would catch up to this level,” said Navin Chaddha, a venture capitalist with Silicon Valley firm Mayfield, which invested in Lyft in 2011.

From its earliest days, Uber aggressively outraised Lyft by billions of dollars, employing tactics such as prohibiting prospective investors who reviewed Uber’s financial data from investing in the smaller competitor.

Just five years ago, some investors were convinced that Lyft would fail, and board members discussed finding a replacement for CEO Logan Green.

Lyft Chairman Sean Aggarwal said on Friday the company will continue to prioritize North American growth over international expansion after completing its IPO. Uber is in more than 70 countries, although it has consolidated certain overseas markets, while Lyft has stuck to the United States and Canada.

“Sticking with that playbook of owning this market (North America) and expanding in this market is how we get to deliver to our public shareholders and the long-term expectations that we set,” Aggarwal said on the sidelines of Lyft’s IPO celebration on Friday.

Lyft has explored expanding its service to Australia and Mexico, sources previously told Reuters.

Aggarwal also said the company’s co-founders, CEO Green and President John Zimmer, worked in recent weeks to make investors comfortable with Lyft’s dual-class share structure, which has faced criticism from some investors and corporate governance advocates.

Although it is common among highly valued tech companies, public market investors still balk at this structure, which gives founders more votes per share and outsized control of the company, long after it is startup-sized. Lyft’s structure will give the founders and certain other shareholders 20 votes per share. 

Celebration at an auto dealership 

Instead of celebrating the first day of trading at the Nasdaq in New York, Lyft opted to mark the occasion at a defunct auto dealership in downtown Los Angeles.

Lyft’s staff, with family and friends, and Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti gathered before dawn for the kickoff. The building, unmarked on the outside, gave away nothing about the celebration tucked away in the bowels of the old facility, which had been outfitted with pink confetti and Lyft-branded scooters.

Lyft recently bought the facility to turn it into a driver services center, the first of several it plans to open across the United States in the coming months, where drivers can obtain services like help with taxes or charging electric vehicles.

Garcetti said in his remarks that the old warehouse symbolizes “a transformation of our economy.”

He pointed out that CEO Green is a native of Los Angeles, adding that “some good did come out of Los Angeles traffic.”