The US Supreme Court on Tuesday blocked a Texas law that bars large social media companies from banning or censoring users based on “viewpoint,” siding with two technology industry groups that have argued that the Republican-backed measure would turn platforms into “havens of the vilest expression imaginable.”
The justices, in a 5-4 decision, granted a request by NetChoice and the Computer & Communications Industry Association, which count Facebook, Twitter and YouTube as members, to block the law while litigation continues after a lower court on May 11 let it go into effect.
For the latest headlines, follow our Google News channel online or via the app.
The industry groups sued to try to block the law, challenging it as a violation of the free speech rights of companies, including to editorial discretion on their platforms, under the US Constitution’s First Amendment.
Conservative Justices Samuel Alito, Clarence Thomas, and Neil Gorsuch issued a written dissent, saying that it is “not at all obvious how our existing precedents, which predate the age of the internet, should apply to large social media companies.” Liberal Justice Elena Kagan separately dissented but did not offer any reasons.
The Texas law was passed by the state’s Republican-led legislature and signed by its Republican governor. Its passage comes as US conservatives and right-wing commentators complain that “Big Tech” is suppressing their views. These people cite as a prominent example Twitter’s permanent suspension of Republican former President Donald Trump from the platform shortly after the January 6, 2021, attack on the US Capitol by a mob of his supporters, with the company citing “the risk of further incitement of violence.”
The law, formally known as HB20, forbids social media companies with at least 50 million monthly active users from acting to “censor” users based on “viewpoint,” and allows either users or the Texas attorney general to sue to enforce it.
In signing the bill last September, Texas Governor Greg Abbott said, “There is a dangerous movement by some social media companies to silence conservative ideas and values. This is wrong and we will not allow it in Texas.”
The industry groups said the state’s law would unconstitutionally allow for government control of private speech. Restricting the platforms’ editorial control, the groups said, “would compel platforms to disseminate all sorts of objectionable viewpoints -- such as Russia’s propaganda claiming that its invasion of Ukraine is justified.”
“Instead of platforms engaging in editorial discretion, platforms will become havens of the vilest expression imaginable: pro-Nazi speech, hostile foreign government propaganda, pro-terrorist-organization speech, and countless more examples,” they added.
The groups also denounced what they called “viewpoint discrimination” against ‘Big Tech,’ in the Texas law through its exclusion of smaller social media platforms popular among conservatives such as Parler, Gab, Gettr and Trump’s own Truth Social.
US Judge Robert Pitman in the state capital Austin blocked the law last December. Pitman ruled that the constraints on how the platforms disseminate content violate the First Amendment.
The New Orleans-based 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals subsequently put Pitman’s decision on hold two days after hearing oral arguments in the case. The 5th Circuit has yet to issue a ruling on the merits of the case.
Apple faces EU antitrust fine over mobile payments technologyApple faces a possible hefty fine and may have to open its mobile payment system to competitors after EU antitrust regulators charged the iPhone maker ... Technology
Back to reality: Snap Inc. CEO Spiegel talks AR tech, weighs in on new featuresSnap Inc., Snapchat’s parent company, announced the launch of an array of new features at its annual Snap Partner Summit. The camera company’s CEO and ... Features
Musk-owned Twitter will have to respect EU tech laws: Commissioner BretonThe European Union warned billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk on Tuesday that his soon-to-be acquired online platform Twitter will have to comply with ... Technology
Another Pentagon official exits, saying US is at risk of losing tech edgeDunlap said the Pentagon, which he dubbed “the world’s largest bureaucracy,” needed to stop focusing on internal turf wars and reinventing the wheel and instead work together to tap the private sector, defend the country and compete with China. World News
Europe to launch multi-billion euro tech fund, says French finance ministerA new publicly funded multi-billion euro fund is being created to boost investment in Europe’s tech sector, to allow it to compete with US and Asian ... Technology
India on collision course with US tech giants as fake news issue heats upIndian officials have held heated discussions with Google, Twitter and Facebook for not proactively removing what they described as fake news on their ... World News
PIF’s partnership with SoftBank an unprecedented success in tech investingSovereign wealth funds the world over have grown more aggressive in unlocking the most promising investments that bring long-term returns and maximize ... Economy