Kerry’s plan for al-Aqsa leaves many issues unanswered

Analysts say steps announced by U.S. secretary of state over the weekend did little to address the deeper issues behind the ongoing violence

Published: Updated:
Enable Read mode
100% Font Size

John Kerry’s latest Mideast mission has aimed for the modest goal of easing tensions around occupied Jerusalem’s most sensitive holy site — the focal point of more than a month of deadly unrest.

But the steps announced by the U.S. secretary of state over the weekend did little to address the deeper issues behind the fighting, disappointing the Palestinians and raising fears that even if calm is restored, it is just a matter of time before another round of violence erupts.


During a swing through the region, Kerry announced the steps on Saturday after several days of meetings with Israeli, Palestinian and Jordanian leaders. The highlight was a Jordanian proposal to install surveillance cameras at the holy site.

More than a month of violence has been fueled by rumors that Israel is trying to change the delicate status quo at the al-Aqsa Mosque compound, which allows non-Muslims to visit but not pray.

While Israel has repeatedly said there are no plans to change this status quo, the Palestinian fears have been stoked by growing numbers of Jewish visitors, backed by some senior Israeli officials, who seek prayer rights and an expanded presence on the mount.

Addressing his Cabinet on Sunday, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he “made clear” to Kerry that Israel is committed to preserving the status quo, and he welcomed the plan to install cameras.

“Israel has an interest in stationing cameras in all parts of the Temple Mount. First, in order to disprove the claim that Israel is changing the status quo. Second, to show where the provocations really come from and to foil them before they ever happen,” he said.

Historical context

Israeli officials said the plan was for Israeli police and officials from the Waqf, the Jordanian-backed religious authority that administers the Muslim sites, to have access to footage.

Palestinian officials gave the camera plan a cool reception.

“Netanyahu wants the video cameras just to track our people and arrest them,” Palestinian official Saeb Erekat told the Voice of Palestine radio station.

Both Israeli and Jordanian officials said arrangements have not yet been discussed in detail, and it was not clear when the cameras would start operating. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the matter with the media.

The conflicting claims to the Aqsa Mosque lie at the heart of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and have spilled over into violence in the past. The current round of fighting began last month with clashes between young Muslim men and Israeli security forces, and quickly spread to other parts of occupied Jerusalem, across Israel and into the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

In five weeks, 10 Israelis have been killed in attacks, mostly stabbings, while 50 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli fire, including 29 said by Israel to be alleged attackers.

On Sunday, Mohammed Hussein, the mufti of Jerusalem, the top Muslim cleric, gave a rare interview to Israeli media, telling Channel 2 TV that there had never been a Jewish presence at the holy site.

“The Al-Aqsa Mosque was there 3,000 years ago, and 30,000 years ago and when the world was created,” he said. “It was never anything other than a mosque.”

Kerry’s plan

Netanyahu has said the stabbings are the result of Palestinian incitement and pointed to comments like the mufti’s. But Palestinians say the violence is the result of deep frustrations after nearly 50 years of Israeli occupation, years of failed peace efforts and a lack of hope for gaining independence.

In his public comments Saturday, Kerry gave no indication that the Obama administration has any plans to re-launch peace efforts during its final year in office, though the so-called Quartet, a U.S.-led group of international Mideast mediators, is to send a delegation to the region in the near future.

During Saturday’s meeting with Kerry, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas raised a number of concerns, including continued Israeli settlement construction on occupied lands claimed by the Palestinians and their demand for an independent state in the West Bank, east Jerusalem and Gaza — lands captured by Israel in the 1967 Mideast war. The Palestinians are seeking a U.N. Security Council resolution endorsing their positions, along with a timeline for establishment of an independent state.

Palestinians said they were waiting to see whether the arrangements announced by Kerry would change the situation on the ground.

On Friday, Israel lifted age restrictions barring young men from joining prayers at the mosque, a key source of tension, and prayers passed without incident. Palestinians also want to see whether Israeli will remove checkpoints and roadblocks placed in Arab neighborhoods in Jerusalem in recent weeks.

Nathan Thrall, an analyst with the International Crisis Group, said there were no guarantees that Kerry’s efforts would even get the latest violence to subside. But he said the U.S. has signaled that it may take one last push at advancing peace.

“We haven’t seen the end of the Obama administration’s involvement or efforts in this conflict,” he said. “I think there is a good chance that the U.S. will wind up doing something ... before the end of Obama’s term.

Top Content Trending