Russian plane crash: How safe are our airports?
Experts consider that baggage controls are, on the whole, reliable and that the biggest risks come from collusion by airport personnel
Airport safety is in the spotlight after a Russian plane crashed in the Sinai Peninsula, with investigators suspecting it was brought down by a bomb inside the aircraft.
Experts consider that baggage controls are, on the whole, reliable and that the biggest risks come from collusion by airport personnel.
Here we take a closer look at the issue.
How is hold luggage checked?
The first control is carried out by the airline to ensure that each passenger who checks in baggage is actually on the plane. "This is an international obligation," explains Sebastien Caron, director general of ASCT International, a French-based company that specialises in airport security.
"In France and in Europe, check-in baggage is then passed through an advanced automatic X-ray machine that can detect 99 percent of the molecules used in explosives," he added.
"On average 30 percent of luggage needs to be checked by a security agent who will then send around five percent of the luggage, for which doubts remain, to another machine, a tomograph (CAT scanner) which operates like a medical scanner.
"At this point 99 percent of the luggage is sent on to the (plane) holds, but if at the end of this stage the security services believe additional verification is required then the owner of the bag in question is called into a search room and the bag is opened.
"Elsewhere in the world the security system is often the same, but we don't have details of the equipment used at Sharm el-Sheikh airport," from where the ill-fated Russian plane took off on October 31, Caron said.
How reliable is this system?
"The reliability levels are very high," for the checking of luggage, thanks notably to the X-rays so that "since the 1980s no one has been able to get a bomb" into a plane's hold, according to French aviation security expert and former pilot Xavier Tytelman.
But "we know that in a general sense there are flaws," he added.
"A large metal plate," could, for example, be used to hide explosive material from scanning machine operators.
"Normally if there is any doubt," the operator will take the suspect bag for a manual search, but this takes time and manpower.
How could someone get around the security systems?
Caron says weak spots remain.
"There are carry-on bags that could be brought on, voluntarily or not, by passengers. There remains a vulnerability in the holds given the volume of baggage moved and the density of (some of) those objects," he told AFP.
Added to that is the storage and provision of on-board meals and the equipment used to clean planes which involves more personnel who "could be complicit in introducing illicit items, or intruders sneaking into restricted areas," he added.
"In most cases (of successful or attempted attacks) airport personnel are involved. A baggage handler could very well, once the bags are checked in, add a booby-trapped bag in the hold. But this involvement is not necessarily voluntary, because someone could, for example, put pressure on an airport worker.
"Statistically, there is an attempt in international airports every six months, which could potentially have grave consequences."
‘Bribe and prejudice:’ How paying $30 can ‘bypass’ Egypt airport securitySecurity in Sharm el-Sheikh airport came under scrutiny amid growing concerns the plane was downed by a bomb smuggled aboard Features
Saint Petersburg bells toll 224 times for Egypt crash victimsAt the St. Isaac’s Cathedral held an emotional memorial service for the passengers that died on the Russian plane that crashed World News
UK plane entering Sharm ‘missed rocket by 300m’ in AugustThe incident happened around two months before a Russian tourist plane leaving the Red Sea resort plummeted from the sky Middle East
Bomb ‘may have been carried’ onto Russian planeU.S. and UK say it’s possible an explosive caused the Saint Petersburg-bound jet but Russia and Egypt have downplayed the theory Middle East
Houthis ‘delay departure’ of Russian aid planeThe spokesman of the Saudi-led coalition said the move was an attempt to attract international attention Middle East
One of two black boxes from Russian plane damaged: Egypt ministryThe ministry said the second black box which contains the cockpit voice recorder (CVR) was partially damaged Middle East
Russia doubts ISIS claim that it shot down airlinerEgyptian authorities found the Russian plane's black box as relatives of the crash's 224 victims mourned the disaster back home Middle East
U.S., Russia sign memo to avoid clashes in air over SyriaPentagon said U.S.-led coalition aircrafts bombing Islamic State in Syria were re-routed at least once to avoid a close encounter with Russian planes Middle East