Latest Google anti-trust remedies ‘not acceptable’, says EU
The Spanish Data Protection Agency accused Google of “illegal processing of personal data”
The latest remedies offered by U.S. giant Google to complaints that it abuses its dominant position in the Internet search market do not go far enough, the European Commission said on Friday.
“The latest proposals are not acceptable in the sense that they are not proposals that can eliminate our concerns regarding competition,” EU Competition Commissioner Joaquin Almunia told Spanish national radio, adding that it was still too early to talk of sanctions.
However, the Spanish Data Protection Agency accused Google of “illegal processing of personal data” on Thursday.
Spain’s data protection watchdog ordered the company to pay a 900,000-euro fine for “serious violations” of users’ privacy.
The Spanish Data Protection Agency accused the popular search provider of “illegal processing of personal data” obtained from users of various services such as Google email accounts.
“Google unlawfully collects and processes personal information” of users, the Spanish agency said in a statement.
“The agency considers that Google seriously violates the right to the protection of personal data.”
It also accused Google of keeping the data for longer than is legally justified and of making it difficult for users to query the use of their data.
Google spokespeople could not immediately be reached to comment to AFP on Thursday but El Pais newspaper quoted the company as saying it had been "totally involved" in the agency's investigations.
It would “read the report carefully and then decide what steps to take next,” the newspaper quoted Google as saying.
The Spanish authority launched proceedings against Google in June. In September, France too said it would take action against the company, accusing it of breaching privacy norms.
Authorities in Germany, Italy, The Netherlands and Britain have also opened parallel procedures against Google.
The Spanish agency said it was the first of these six authorities to make a final decision on action against the U.S. giant.
The European Union warned Google in October 2012 that its new data protection procedures did not comply with an EU directive on the subject and gave the company four months to change them.
That deadline passed without any action, prompting France to set up the task force of individual member states pursuing the issue with Google.
Google has defended the changes it made last year, saying they simplify and standardize its approach across its various services.
Critics say the policy gives the operator of the world’s largest search engine unprecedented ability to monitor its users.
Like other technology giants, Google has come under heightened scrutiny in recent months following revelations by U.S. whistleblower Edward Snowden of online eavesdropping by intelligence agencies.
The Spanish Data Protection Agency is a state body with power to impose fines and to order data to be destroyed, according to its website.
In 2010 it filed a suit against Google for allegedly capturing data from Internet users when it collected photos for its Street View map service.