Extended Iran nuclear talks leave bomb investigation in limbo
The IAEA is still trying to conduct a separate, but related, inquiry into weapons research suspicions
A stalled U.N. watchdog investigation into allegations Iran conducted atomic bomb research looks unlikely to be revived by the decision to extend wider nuclear talks, diplomats and experts say.
While negotiations continue on a deal to curb Iran’s uranium enrichment capacity -- to lengthen the time needed should Tehran ever decide to assemble nuclear weapons -- the International Atomic Energy Agency is still trying to conduct a separate, but related, inquiry into weapons research suspicions.
Western diplomats who accuse Iran of stonewalling the IAEA say full cooperation with the U.N. agency should be a condition for sanctions relief under the broader nuclear deal.
But when talks between Iran and six world powers were extended on Monday, there was no indication that there was any new requirement for Iran to engage with the IAEA before a possible comprehensive settlement is reached.
“Can Iran now stall with impunity until July 1, 2015?” asked one Western diplomat, referring to the talks’ new deadline.
The IAEA has for years sought access to sites and officials in Iran to clarify intelligence reports, contained in its 2011 report, indicating activities with possible relevance to atomic bombs, mostly happening until about a decade ago but some of which, the agency said, might be ongoing.
Iran denies any plan to develop nuclear weapons and says the accusations were forged by its enemies. It has declined to give IAEA inspectors free rein.
A senior U.S. official said the possible military dimensions -- or PMD in diplomats’ jargon -- of the nuclear program must be addressed for there to be a deal to lift the sanctions that have crippled Iran’s economy.
“We’ve always said that any agreement must resolve the issue to our satisfaction,” the official said last week.
Another diplomat said: “The leverage is the sanctions.”
But many experts say the historical allegations may never be clarified and efforts should focus on ensuring that weapons development, if it happened, has been halted.
Cliff Kupchan, of risk consultancy Eurasia Group, predicted “more deadlock” for the IAEA investigation.
“The best we can hope for on PMD is no future activity. I just don’t think they’ll talk about the past to a meaningful extent,” Kupchan said.
Ali Vaez, of think-tank International Crisis Group, said it would be in Iran’s interest to cooperate more closely with the IAEA probe, to blunt criticism by sceptics who say Iran is just using the diplomacy to play for time:
“If the extension has provided more time for the detractors to scuttle the diplomatic process, Iran’s lack of cooperation with the agency will provide them with more ammunition.”
There may still be some progress in the inquiry in coming months but Iran will only really open up to the IAEA after a political accord with the United States, France, Germany, Britain, Russia and China, Vaez said.
Iran nuclear talks extended until end of JuneIran and world powers agreed to continue talks during the coming weeks: state media Middle East
Panorama: At look at Iran's nuclear talksNews Bulletins
Khamenei says West will not defeat IranKhamenei says West could not bring Iran to its knees in the nuclear negotiations Middle East
Iran’s hardline media slam nuclear talks extensionVatan-e-Emrooz, a hardline broadsheet title, headlined its front page “Nothing” and beneath the fold had only empty white space Television & Radio
Iran can build ‘any’ weapon: IRGCAny U.S. aggression against the Islamic Republic could push Tehran to send its troop to liberate the occupied Palestinian territories Middle East
The nuclear game: win-win extension for U.S. and Iran“Both Iran and the U.S. appear to gain geopolitical, geostrategic, and economic interests from this extension:” Majid Rafizadeh Analysis
Israel’s Netanyahu hails failure to reach Iran dealThe West wants uranium enrichment in Iran dramatically reduced Middle East
Iran parliament suggests $75-80/bbl oil price for budgetGholamreza Tajgardoon said that if the budget was based on a higher price, it would increase the chances of a budget deficit Energy
1800GMT: Iran, major powers discuss new nuclear deal deadlineNews Bulletins
Kerry, Saudi FM hold talks in ViennaAl-Faisal meets Kerry to discuss latest updates on nuclear talks with Iran Middle East
Iranians support Iran's nuclear programIran and six world powers are holding talks in Vienna to reach a lasting agreement on Tehran's disputed nuclear programme before November 24. Such a ... Perspective
Iran media weighs in on nuclear deal optionsReformist newspaper Ebtekar supported the talks Saturday, saying the need to bargain hard has led to the brinkmanship in Vienna Print
Kerry: ‘gaps’ remain in Iran nuclear talksThere had been 'no significant' progress so far on the main stumbling blocks of Iran’s uranium enrichment capacity Middle East
Outcome of Iran nuclear talks ‘completely open:’ German FMGerman Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier said Saturday that the outcome of Iran’s nuclear talks with six world powers was ... Middle East
France tempers Iran nuclear stance in nod to wider diplomatic needsFrance has long held out for strict terms trading a loosening of international sanctions on Iran Features