Experts warn killing top ISIS leaders not enough to cripple group
Analysts warn that disruptions of this type are often fleeting
The Pentagon has hailed the deaths of several top leaders of the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria(ISIS), but experts say this is far from enough to cripple what has proven to be a resilient organization.
U.S. officials say air strikes have killed several senior and mid-level Islamist militants including Abu Muslim al-Turkmani, the right hand man of ISIS chief Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, dealing a serious blow to the group's operations.
But analysts warn that disruptions of this type are often fleeting and that the U.S.-led coalition needs to look beyond their military campaign to weaken the group that has become the world's most feared jihadist organization since proclaiming a "caliphate" straddling Syria and Iraq six months ago.
"Eliminating key leaders is a means to disrupt plots and degrade capabilities. But they do not defeat or destroy terrorist organizations," said Bruce Riedel, a former CIA agent and adviser to U.S. President Barack Obama who is now a leading terrorism expert.
"Al-Qaeda in Iraq lost its top leadership twice but still thrived sufficiently to give birth to the Islamic State."
Pentagon spokesman Rear Admiral John Kirby said strikes against the group's leadership were disrupting the jihadists' "ability to command and control current operations against" Iraqi federal and Kurdish forces.
But the real impact is hard to quantify, especially as the command structure of ISIS is largely a mystery to intelligence services, with its members masters at disguising themselves through a multitude of false identities, nicknames and noms de guerre.
And the Western view of a pyramid-like command structure with a supreme leader, deputies and cascading line of subordinates does not take into account a reality where tribal, regional, cultural and historical ties often take precedence.
Even if militant supremo Baghdadi was killed, this would not see the ideology that spurred the creation of the so-called “caliphate” crumble overnight.
"If Baghdadi is out of the picture before his caliphate is firmly established, the Islamic State group will be seriously challenged, but with resourceful lieutenants in charge, it will not be finished without a further fight," said Michael Ryan of the Washington-based Jamestown Foundation.
U.S. officials have been open about the limits of the military operation and have warned the West will have to dig in for the long haul to combat IS.
Military chief Gen. Martin Dempsey recently told the U.S. Senate that ISIS would "ultimately be defeated when their cloak of religious legitimacy is stripped away and the population on which they have imposed themselves reject them.
"Our actions are intended to move in that direction. This will require a sustained effort over an extended period of time. It is a generational problem, and we should expect that our enemies will adapt their tactics as we adjust our approach."
U.S.-led air strikes kill several ISIS leadersHaji Mutazz, a key deputy to Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, was among those killed in the strikes, officials told the Wall Street Journal Middle East
ISIS in Iraq beheads man it accuses of ‘sorcery’Some residents who spoke to AFP said the executed man was a Sunni who had recently joined the police in Samarra Middle East
Anti-ISIS fight to take at least three years: U.S. generalKurdish Peshmerga forces say they are rolling back ISIS militants around Sinjar Middle East
Experts fear ISIS adding malware to digital arsenalThe concerns were sparked by a botched cyberattack aimed at unmasking Syrian dissidents Digital