A Detroit suburb’s plan to ban cooking or sleeping in household garages has some in the large Arab community worried they won’t be able to use them to meet relatives and friends for coffee or tea, and smoke cigarettes or share a hookah.
Dearborn city officials say their efforts are aimed at keeping cars off streets and making sure garages are being safely and properly used. They want to limit “living” activities.
A city attorney is working on revisions to the ordinance, and it’s expected to be ready for consideration by the Planning Commission on July 8.
Many who hang out in garages are part of Dearborn’s nearly 100,000 Arab-American residents, one of the largest such communities outside of the Middle East and a third of the city’s population. The garages are a continuation of marathon socializing sessions that started many years ago in their home countries under shady trees, often accompanied by coffee and a water pipe, known as a hookah or argileh.
“They migrated over time to the garage as an extension of the living place, and here comes the complaint from people who don’t have that as part of their tradition,” said Nabeel Abraham, a Dearborn resident and an instructor and administrator at a Dearborn community college. “I think it’s a class, ethnic reaction.”
Not so, say Dearborn officials, who say the ordinance-tightening isn’t meant to target Arabs or anyone else. They don’t want the garages, which they contend aren’t built to the same standards as the rest of a home, to become “habitable” places for cooking or sleeping.
They say the structures aren’t meant to be living spaces, so building permits can’t be issued to convert them. That conversion, city spokeswoman Mary Laundroche said, is not only illegal but also isn’t inspected for safety.
“We’re trying to find a solution that is safe and acknowledges the way garages are being used,” she said.
Muheeb Nabulsy and his wife, Fatima Mkkawi, attended a meeting this spring to explain what they do in their garages - and what they don’t. They were each issued citations last summer and the doors were inspected, though their court challenges are ongoing.
Laundroche said the city is trying to work with residents and enforcement “has been put on hold.”
The interiors of Nabulsy’s and Khalaf’s garages resemble patios outfitted with furniture, TVs and tile floors, but also incorporate storage areas typical of any garage.
Nabulsy said he and his wife were inspired by sliding doors on a nearby garage after renovating their house. They no longer wanted to smoke inside their home but liked having fresh air, a street view and protection from insects and the elements, so they installed their own.
But both said they received “stop-work orders” and visits by a city inspector. Nabulsy said an inspector came twice and saw nothing objectionable, but he hasn’t yet received a permit.
“When (the inspector) entered the garage, he said, ‘I don’t know why I’m here,’” Nabulsy said over coffee and cigarettes during a recent evening in neighbor Miriam Khalaf’s garage. Both even fashioned ramps that allow vehicles to get over the door frames and into the garage.
What any new ordinance will say is unclear. A city attorney is still working on a draft of the revision, which is expected to be ready for the Planning Commission’s consideration at its July 8 meeting. An early version prohibited sliding doors and tile floors.
What’s tricky is how to define “living space.”
“I think your home is your home,” said commission Chairman Gary Errigo. “There was someone who spoke who said they're sitting in their garage in a lounge chair and a police car drives by and they pack up their chair and run inside. It shouldn’t be like that, and it’s not like that.”
Errigo doesn’t think having a spare refrigerator in the garage is a problem, but he doesn’t want the structures to become crash pads or places where meals are prepared. In that case, they should be evaluated and taxed accordingly.
If the ordinance is approved by the Planning Commission, the City Council will have the final say.
Abraham said city officials will have to ensure that any changes are enforced evenly and fairly across ethnic, class and neighborhood lines.
“What’s the difference between sitting together and smoking an argileh or cigar and having tea, or having a homemade brew?” said Abraham, who doesn’t have a garage hangout. “This town has a law for everything and anything - (it) needs to loosen up a little bit.”