Monkey cannot own copyright to selfie, U.S. judge rules
Monkey who took internationally famous selfie cannot own the copyrights to the picture because he is not human
A rare crested macaque that took a now internationally famous “selfie” cannot own the copyright to the photograph because he is not human, a U.S. judge ruled in a suit brought by animal rights group PETA on behalf of the monkey.
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals brought the case in September on behalf of the seven-year-old monkey Naruto against British photographer David Slater, who self-published the photo in a wildlife book.
Naruto, who resides on a reserve in Indonesia, took the image and several others in 2011 using a camera left unattended by Slater, the suit said. PETA argued he should be declared owner of the photos and receive damages for copyright infringement that would be used for habitat preservation.
While the U.S. Congress and the president have the power to extend legal protections to animals as well as humans, “there is no indication that they did so in the Copyright Act,” U.S. District Judge William Orrick said at a hearing on Wednesday in federal court in San Francisco, according to a court transcript.
But Orrick said he would give PETA an opportunity to amend the lawsuit before he dismisses it outright. PETA published the photo in the case online at bit.ly/1V8Hnnl.
PETA General Counsel Jeff Kerr told Reuters on Thursday that the group is reviewing its legal options.
“Although we are disappointed, we are celebrating the fact that this is a historic case,” he said. “For the first time we are arguing that an animal can own property, rather than merely being a piece of property himself.”
Slater, who said that fewer than 100 copies of the book have been sold worldwide despite the publicity, asked Orrick in November to throw out the case because, he argued, animals do not have legal standing. “Monkey see, monkey sue is not good law,” he said in court papers.
Slater’s lawyer, Andrew Dhuey, said that even if PETA can now amend its lawsuit, Orrick will likely rule in his client’s favor.
“My tuxedo cats could have won this case,” he said. “It’s not a complicated situation. All that really matters is that the plaintiff is a monkey.”
Monkey ‘selfies’ spark copyright war with WikipediaUnder U.S. law, 'copyright cannot vest in non-human authors' Digital
Deep-voiced monkeys may be ‘all talk,’ study findsA study found that male howler monkeys with the most powerful voices also had the smallest testicles Variety
Sneezing monkeys and ‘walking’ fish?In the forests of northern Myanmar, scientists learnt in 2010 of a black and white monkey with an upturned nose that causes it to sneeze when it rains Variety
David Beckham look-a-like monkey becomes big hit in ChinaBeckham first appeared with the iconic Mohican hairstyle back in 2001 Sports
Espanyol cited for monkey chants, Pique abuseAlba, a Spain international, was also verbally abused as he left the pitch, the LFP said Sports
New drug shields monkeys from version of HIV: studyMacaque monkeys given the drug were able to fend off high, repeated doses of the simian version of HIV Healthy Living
Monkey gives first aid to electrocuted friendThe injured monkey had fallen between the tracks, apparently after touching high-tension wires Variety
Ronaldinho called ‘monkey’ by former city officialRonaldinho signed for Queretaro two weeks ago and is expected to play his first match this week Sports