Gaza doesn’t need a Gandhi, it has its own heroes
As great as Gandhi was in the context of his country’s struggle, Palestine has its own heroes
“Where is the Palestinian Gandhi? In Israeli prison, of course!” was the title of an article by Jo Ehrlich published in Modoweiss.net on Dec 21, 2009. That was almost exactly one year after Israel’s concluded a major war against Gaza. The so-called Operation Cast Lead (December 27, 2008 – January 18, 2009) was, until then, the deadliest Israeli attack against the impoverished strip for many years.
Ehrlich was not in the least being belittling by raising the question about the “Palestinian Gandhi” but responding to the patronization of others. Right from the onset, he remarked: “Not that I’m in any way playing into the Palestinian Gandhi dialogue, I think it’s actually pretty diversionary/racist. But sometimes you have to laugh in order not to cry.”
Indeed, the question was, and remains condescending, ignorant, patronizing and utterly racist. But the question was also pervasive, including among people who classify themselves as “pro-Palestinian activists.”
Although the disparity of the fight between Israeli and Palestinian resistance is as highlighted today as ever before, Palestinian resistance has maturedRamzy Baroud
Now that Israel’s latest war – so-called Operation Protective Edge – has surpassed Cast Lead, in terms of duration, causalities, level of destruction, but also the sheer horrendousness of its targeting of civilians, as dozens of families were entirely wiped out – the Gandhi question seems more muted than usual. To understand why, one needs to first examine the reason of why Palestinians were demanded to produce a non-violent Gandhi alternative in their struggle for freedom in the first place.
The Second Palestinian Intifada or uprising (2000-2005) was inaugurated with an extremely violent Israeli response. Israeli leaders at the time meant to send a message to late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat that they had no patience for any act of collective defiance, as they were convinced that Arafat engineered the Intifada to strengthen his political possession in the “peace talks,” which, ultimately proved a farce.
Caught in an impossible situation – massive U.S.-fed Israeli war machine that harvested hundreds of lives every month– and having no faith in their leadership, Palestinians resorted to arms, using suicide bombings as well as other violent methods. The tactic raised much controversy – due to the death toll among Israeli civilians – and was quickly used in Israel-Western propaganda to, retrospectively explain Israel’s military occupation, and justify its harsh military tactics.
Those who dared explain Palestinian violence within its proper and larger context, or underscore that many more Palestinian civilians were still being killed by the Israeli army were shunned by the media, and, at times, were seen as a liability by those who insisted to classify Palestinians within a narrative of victimization.
Many Westerners (from presidents, to philosophers, to journalists, to social media activists) deliberated the matter with much enthusiasm. The fact that few Western countries have truly experienced anti-colonial national liberation struggle in its modern history, thus lack real understanding of the humiliation and anger experienced by colonized nations, seemed to matter little. Some were simply concerned about Israel, and no one else; others, wanted to preserve the image of the Palestinian as an occupied, hapless, eternal victim.
The most obscene presentation of this language was made by then-newly elected U.S. President Barack Obama, who stood at a Cairo university podium on June 4, 2009, to convey to Palestinians a most denigrating, insensitive and highly inaccurate message:
“Palestinians must abandon violence. Resistance through violence and killing is wrong and it does not succeed. For centuries, black people in America suffered the lash of the whip as slaves and the humiliation of segregation. But it was not violence that won full and equal rights. This same story can be told by people from South Africa to South Asia; from Eastern Europe to Indonesia. It's a story with a simple truth: that violence is a dead end.”
Obama’s message painted the Palestinian struggle as an abnormality in an otherwise a perfectly peaceful national liberation struggles around the world. The message is of course untrue. More, he either didn’t know or wished to ignore Palestinian history where popular, nonviolent resistance that goes back to the 1920s and 30s, and arguably, earlier than that. Obama, like many others, failed to appreciate the level of extreme Israeli violence, which supposedly employs weapons that Obama had himself supplied Tel Aviv, to subdue Palestinian resistance and maintain a relatively easy military occupation and thriving Jewish settlements built illegally on stolen Palestinian land.
But the decisive point in the discussion was the Second Intifada, which wrought much Israeli violence resulting in the death of thousands. The political implications of the uprising were also quite significant as it divided Palestinians between those who were intimidating by the Israeli tactics into submissions (the so-called moderates), and others who seemed unrepentant (the so-called radicals).
For nearly ten years now, the debate raged. Some out rightly condemned Palestinian armed resistance, others offered mutual criticism of Israeli and Hamas violence, while another group simply preached about the futility of armed struggle in the face of a country with nuclear weapons capable of blowing up much of the globe at the push of a button.
That debate, although made for an exquisite discussion on online newspapers and social media, hardly registered amongst ordinary Palestinians, especially those in Gaza. While Gaza intellectuals did contend with new ideas of how to build international solidarity to end the Israeli siege, get their message out to the world, and even question the timing of firing rockets into Israel, few probed the principle of armed resistance.
Palestinians know best
Of course, Palestinians know best, much better than Obama and other preachers elsewhere. They know that collective resistance is not always a tactic determined through social media discussions; that when one’s children are pulverized by U.S.-supplied killing technology, there is no time to lay flat and sing “we shall overcome,” but to prevent the rest of the tanks from entering into the neighborhood – be it Shujaiya, Jabalya or Maghazi. They also know that Israeli violence is a result of a decided political agenda, and is not tailored around the nature of Palestinian resistance. But more importantly, history has taught them, that when Israelis come to Gaza as invaders, few will stand in Gaza’s defense but Gaza’s own sons and daughters. If Gazans don’t defend their cities, no one else will.
Although the disparity of the fight between Israeli and Palestinian resistance is as highlighted today as ever before, Palestinian resistance has matured. The fact that they killed dozens of soldiers and only three civilians should be noted, as is Israel’s disgraceful targeting of hospitals, schools, U.N. shelters and even graveyards. Maintaining that level of discipline in the most unequalled fight one can imagine is as close to the very battlefield ethics that the U.S. and Israel often breach, but never, ever respect.
As great as Gandhi was in the context of his country’s struggle against colonialism, which remains a source of inspiration for many Palestinians, Palestine has its own heroes, resisters, women and men who are engraving a legend of their own in Gaza and the rest of Palestine.
As for those who have busily asked the question of where is the Palestinian Gandhi, it is much more affective for them to use their energies to block their governments’ shipments of weapons to Israel, which, as of August 6, killed nearly 1,900 and wounded over 9,500, the vast majority of whom are civilians.
Palestinian-American journalist, author, editor, Ramzy Baroud (www.ramzybaroud.net) taught Mass Communication at Australia's Curtin University of Technology, and is Editor-in-Chief of the Palestine Chronicle. Baroud's work has been published in hundreds of newspapers and journals worldwide and his books “His books “Searching Jenin: Eyewitness Accounts of the Israeli Invasion” and “The Second Palestinian Intifada: A Chronicle of a People’s Struggle” have received international recognition. Baroud’s third book, “My Father Was a Freedom Fighter: Gaza's Untold Story” narrates the story of the life of his family, used as a representation of millions of Palestinians in Diaspora, starting in the early 1940’s until the present time.
Messi defends rights of Gaza childrenArgentinian footballer Lionel Messi says ‘I am terribly saddened by the images coming from the conflict between Israel and Palestine’ Life
Ex-Hamas spokesman found dead in shelled Gaza neighborhoodAyman Taha was killed in the Shejaiya neighbourhood Middle East
Trapped in Gaza, young people dream of a better lifeYoung people in Gaza say the security situation means they have little to do after work and studies Features
Israel’s 2014 budget will absorb cost of Gaza conflict, minister saysThe finance minister there will be no need to raise taxes due to the costly month-long Gaza conflict Economy
Healthcare crisis threatens to tip Gaza over the edgeWhile diplomatically, progress is slowly being made, the overwhelmed hospitals in Gaza are in dire need of medicine Middle East
The ‘winner’ of the war on GazaThe destruction, the nearly 2,000 Palestinians killed and the 7,000 injured, does not seem much of a victory Middle East
Senior Hamas official Marzouk says ‘no agreement’ on Gaza truce extensionA senior Hamas official tweeted “There is no agreement on the extension of the truce” Middle East
Israel-Palestinian talks on Gaza underway in CairoA Palestinian delegate says the ceasefire, set to expire at 0500 GMT Friday would likely be extended if more time for talks is needed Middle East
Gaza border town in ruins after Israeli attackAlmost 100 civilians in Gaza killed in one day after Israeli attack Features
Charity lists dead Gaza children in British paper adsReaders are invited to send text messages as part of the campaign to force a permanent ceasefire "for the children of Gaza and Israel". Print
Kerry: Gaza truce should lead to negotiationsKerry explained that a 'broader approach to the underlying' two-state solution would provide security for Israelis Middle East
UAE Water Aid to send drinking water to GazaThe water tanks will be delivered to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) through the Jordanian border Middle East