How the Syrian uprising led to ISIS’ rise, not democracy
The violence of the Syrian uprising transformed Islamist discourse from a rebellion by the Syrian people to a rebellion of Sunnis
This article is a first in a three-part series exploring the erosion of the 2011 Syrian uprising
When mass protests swept through Syria in 2011, its motives were not to establish a caliphate based on religious laws and institutions. The uprising was galvanized by youths, who realized that there is a great disparity between their living status and those in the West.
They craved democracy, freedom of speech, equality and Western values. They have shaped their vision based on bilingual liberal education, and a diverse upbringing with strong Western influence. These youths, however, do not have sufficient expertise to determine effective, enduring methods to realize their aspirations.
Syrian intellectuals also have a vision of progressing people’s lives through social, intellectual and gender reform. However, these elites do not realize the difficulty in achieving this amid a wide gap between them and the masses, whose lives for decades have been shaped by dynastic dictatorship.
Submission and loyalty
These masses developed an interdependent relationship with dictators: bread and security in return for submission and loyalty. Dictatorship fostered this wide gap between the masses and elites through the latter’s disempowerment, arbitrary detention and exile, as well as a lack of freedom of speech. This made the masses afraid to be influenced by the elites, and alienated the latter, who were obliged to either cooperate with the oppressors for survival, or face exile and persecution.
The violence of the Syrian uprising transformed Islamist discourse from a rebellion by the Syrian people to a rebellion of SunnisDr. Halla Diyab
With the onset of the revolution, people joined marches and chanted statements against the atroci-ties committed by those in power. For these people, it was about rebelling in the name of dignity and justice. However, they have no concrete plans for the future, and so can be easily manipulated to join any ideology that calls for rebellion in aid of the oppressed. This group is highly impression-able and driven by emotion.
The Islamists, comprising angry, emotionally-driven sects of Syrian society as well as foreigners, have found an opportunity to take revenge on the secular nationalism that has for decades suppressed them. They are bound by the rhetoric that Islam is the solution to social, economic and po-litical injustice. They include supporters of the Muslim Brotherhood and the Salafi Ansar al-Shariah, which calls for sharia law to be implemented.
They are not necessarily violent or see violence as a way to further their goals, but are bitterly op-posed to the governance of the al-Assad family, which has dealt brutally with Brotherhood since the 1980s. Bashar al-Assad’s father Hafez in March 1973 adopted a constitution that deleted any reference to Islam as the state religion. Islamists view themselves as separate from Arab secularists, who have chosen loyalty to nationalism over Islamism.
Islamists have been attracting moderate Muslim youths, who have witnessed the fall of 20th-century Arab secularism and the pan-Arab nationalism of late Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser. These youths see a revival of Muslim preachers and leaders post 9/11, who publicly took on the responsibility of reforming the international image of Islam and Muslims.
Muslim divisions and social media
The post-9/11 era has given rise to influential Arab preachers, such as moderate TV personality Amr Khaled, Sufi scholar Habib Ali Jifri, Salafist preacher Mohammad al-Arifi, and Brotherhood advocate Tareq Mohammad al-Suwaidan.
They are part of a narrative seeking to replace the Arab nationalist-secular narrative. The 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq, and the diminishing credibility of secular Arab nationalists, created a vacuum, and Islamists see this as an opportunity to gain political dominance.
However, Sunni-Shiite division was not a primary factor in the discourse of leading Muslim preachers post-9/11. The violence of the Syrian uprising transformed Islamist discourse from a rebellion by the Syrian people to a rebellion of Sunnis. Islamist Sunni online forums, social media and websites posting photos and videos of regime abuses fuelled Sunni-Shiite division.
Online videos showed regime troops forcing captured Syrian Sunni fighters to say “la Illah ila Bashar al-Assad” (no God except Bashar al-Assad). Videos also showed Syrian men obliged by regime offic-ers to pray on his photos. Such videos feed sectarianism while ocial media had started to be considered a central source for the Arab Spring’s newfound freedom of speech.
The second and third parts of this article will be published later this week.
Dr. Halla Diyab is an award winning screen-writer, producer, broadcaster, a published author and an activist. She has a Ph.D. in English and American Studies from the University of Leicester. She carried out research in New Orleans, USA while working on her thesis “The Examination of Marginality and Minorities in the Drama and Film of Tennessee Wil-liams”. She holds an MA in Gender and Women Studies from the University of Warwick. She has written a number of scripts for TV dramas countering religious extremism and international terrorism resulting in her being awarded Best Syrian Drama Script Award 2010 and the Artists Achievement Award 2011. She is a regular commentator in the Brit-ish and international media and has recently appeared on Channel 4 News, BBC Newsnight, BBC This Week, CNN, Sky News, Channel 5 News, ITV Central, Al Jazeera English, and BBC Radio 4, to name a few. She is a public speaker who spoke at the House of Commons, the Spectator Debate, Uniting for Peace and London’s Frontline Club. She has worked in Libya, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, and Syria and is an expert on the Middle East and Islamic culture. As a highly successful drama writer, she has been dubbed ‘one of the most influential women in Syria’ in 2011. She also produces documentary films for UK and international channels. She is also the Founder & Director of Liberty Media Productions which focuses on cross-cultural issues between Britain and the Middle East. She can be found on Twitter: @drhalladiyab
Syrian Kurdish fighters struggle to maintain KobaneA statement calls for the EU, Turkey and other regional and international partners to 'isolate and contain' the ISIS threat Middle East
U.S. warns higher chance of ISIS reprisal attacksThe U.S. says it sees a higher chance of reprisal attacks on members of the U.S.-led coalition Middle East
Disillusioned Syrian woman reveals life in ISISKhadija left a few days before the U.S.- led coalition began its airstrikes against ISIS Profiles
Father of James Foley: ‘we must negotiate with ISIS’The Foleys urged reporters to continue their work in war zones despite their loss News
Two weeks on, how effective are the Syria strikes?Kurdish military leaders say U.S.-led airstrikes against ISIS are simply not working Analysis