Bombing ISIS: Is Iran America’s newest ally?
The U.S. this week said that Iran bombed ISIS. The Iranians are denying it, but that is to be expected
The U.S. this week said that Iran bombed ISIS. The Iranians at first denied the news, but then confirmed it - a few days later. The Iranian denial was expected. More than two months ago, Iran’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei released a series of tweets against the U.S.-led coalition against ISIS. The message he conveyed is not new: Iran will not be part of a coalition led by a country – the U.S. - which is a leader in supporting terrorism. So when two-and-half-months later the Americans point to the possibility of an Iranian strike against ISIS, the only natural thing is to deny it. The denial used rhetoric similar to that used by Khamenei: It is out of the question for Iran to cooperate with the U.S., the U.S. should have no place in the futures of Iraq and Syria.
Even before it was confirmed, it would make sense to believe that the bombing actually happened. A few weeks ago news came out about a secret letter by President Obama to Khamenei. The two main points of the letter were on nuclear negotiations and cooperating in fighting terrorism and ISIS. The recent nuclear negotiations did not achieve their objectives. So perhaps the Iranians calculated that their support of U.S. efforts against ISIS would give them leverage in the next round of negotiations. Moreover, the Saudis and the Russians agreed in their latest discussions that the Geneva 1 framework should be the basis of any solution to the Syrian war. It would not be farfetched to say that this agreement diminished the value of ISIS for both Assad and Syria.
Military issues
There is also precedence for U.S.-Iran support in military issues. The Iran-Contra affair (1985-1986) came at a time when the relationship between both countries was much worse than it is today. Yet Iran was willing to support America’s war against the Sandinista government in Nicaragua in return for much needed American weapons. Not only that, Iran was willing to have those weapons delivered through Israel! A more recent but no less significant case of U.S.-Iran military coordination came in 2001 when Iran supported the U.S. coalition against the Taliban.
I’ve personally been very supportive of U.S. - Iranian rapprochement as it will improve the security conditions in the region
Abdullah HamidaddinBoth the U.S. and Iran do not like such news to come out. The most apparent reason is embarrassment and had it not been for footage showing what seemed to be Iranian planes the matter could have been kept under the rug. Iran likes to present itself as an anti-imperialist, Islamic and revolutionary state. But it seems that behind all the idealistic Iranian rhetoric is a shrewd and savage realpolitik. U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry had said last September that coordination with Iran “would not be right for any number of reasons.”
A more probable reason in my view for the U.S. discontent from the revelation of Iran bombing ISIS would be the signals it would send to America’s allies in the region. They believe the U.S. is appeasing Iran, while Iran is working hard and fast to acquire the nuclear weapon. The alleged Iranian bombing could not have happened without some form of direct or indirect coordination with the U.S.; and this propels the concerns of America’s allies to a new level. It was one thing to see the U.S. going soft with Iran’s nuclear ambitions; something else all-together to see some form of military coordination with Iran.
I’ve personally been very supportive of U.S. - Iranian rapprochement as it will improve the security conditions in the region; something which is much needed after more than three and a half decades of disorder. But for it to work America’s allies need to be in the picture. They need to be part of the solution. This is a regional matter not a bilateral one; this is a matter which will redefine the security regime of the regime and all the leading countries in this region should be writing down that new security regime. If that cannot be achieved, I think America’s allies deserve the courtesy of not having to hear the extent of U.S.-Iranian cooperation via satellite channels.
________________________
Abdullah Hamidaddin is a writer and commentator on religion, Middle Eastern societies and politics with a focus on Saudi Arabia and Yemen. He is currently a PhD candidate in King’s College London. He can be followed on Twitter: @amiq1
-
ISIS attacks last govt air base in Deir Ezzor
Assad says he vows to remain in power as the Syrian conflict will be long Middle East -
New group of Iraqi Peshmergas enters Syrian Kurdish town
Kobane has become a powerful international symbol in the battle against ISIS Middle East -
Lebanon: DNA test says child is ISIS head’s daughter
The Interior Minister said the girl and two other children detained with al-Dulaimi are being held in a child care center Middle East -
Arrest of an ISIS ex-wife: Between truth and distortions
It’s been said that truth is the first casualty of war, and it is manifested on full display in Lebanon this week Middle East -
ISIS cedes little ground despite air attacks
U.S. ‘strategic mess’ in Syria helps ISIS Analysis -
France ready to ‘step up’ action against ISIS in Iraq
President Francois Hollande says France was ready ‘to step up actions’ against ISIS in Iraq Middle East -
U.S. general: ISIS has training camps in Libya
General David Rodriguez says ISIS has set up training camps in eastern Libya and the American military is closely monitoring Africa -
Kerry: any Iran action against ISIS ‘positive’
Iran denied taking any action against the militant group operating in Syria and Iraq Middle East -
Saudi FM: fighting ISIS in Syria requires boots on the ground
Prince Saud al-Faisal said there is an ‘urgent’ need for strengthen moderate opposition forces in Syria Middle East -
Obama ‘confident’ on pushing back ISIS in Iraq
John Kerry says the coalition has inflicted serious damage on ISIS but the fight could last years Middle East -
Assad says U.S.-led strikes on Syria ineffective
The coalition said that that the advances of ISIS across Iraq and Syria are being stopped Middle East -
NATO: Iraq will request help with training forces
The Iraqi army is fighting to retake major areas from ISIS Middle East