The Lebanese have always prided themselves on their resilience and their ability to turn adversity into opportunity, or at least this is what the Lebanese myth propagates.
The reality of the matter is somewhat different, as the Lebanese and their political elite have repeatedly failed to rise to the occasion and institute a sovereign and viable nation state.
Over time, the Lebanese state has relinquished many of its prerogatives to the ruling elite, who in turn operate a highly developed clientalist system that uses the state’s resources to strengthen its own powerbase.
Additionally, the Lebanese have relinquished its sovereignty on one of the most important prerequisite of statehood, by allowing Hezbollah to operate its militia unchecked both within Lebanon and across the region.
Recently, the Lebanese state have went a step further in its downwards descend by allowing Hezbollah to publically declare that it will be implementing a plan to ensure or perhaps “force” the return of the 1.2 million Syrian refugees in Lebanon.
Ironically, Hezbollah and fellow Iranian militias are mainly responsible for destroying and later occupying many of these Syrian refugees’ villages and towns.
Both Aoun and Hezbollah wish to use the refugees to serve a number of goals, which primarily include demonizing refugees and the international community, and blame them for Lebanon’s collapsing economyMakram Rabah
In his recent address, Hassan Nasrallah, Secretary General of Hezbollah, declared that his own party would play a facilitating role in the return of the Syrian refugees, a task that in his own mind is made possible due to his party’s excellent relationship with the Assad regime.
Audaciously, Nasrallah further declared that formation of a Hezbollah refugee affairs committee that would submit lists of names to the Syrian government for approval after which these refugees can return home.
The obvious infringement on Lebanon sovereignty exceeds the fact that Nasrallah trusts he can replace the Lebanese state as well as the international community in the refugees crisis, but he also believes that their safe return is isolated from any political settlement of the Syrian crisis.
ALSO READ: Why did Nasrallah suggest peace with ISIS?
Nasrallah’s proposed return-mechanism is outright unsound as the mere screening of refugees by the Assad regime means that the reason for their displacement is still present and the chances of persecution as well.
If Nasrallah truly wants to expedite the return of the refugees in a manner that conforms to international humanitarian standards, he can start by ordering his fighters to evacuate the Qalamoun region across Lebanon’s eastern border, a move that would allow for the immediate return of thousands of refugees.
More importantly, from a policy perspective Hezbollah has allowed its main ally, President Aoun and his son-in-law Gebran Bassil to antagonize and bully the international community and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees-UNHCR and accuse them of conspiring against Lebanon and plotting to naturalize these refugees.
A viable plan
It would be wiser for the Lebanese state and even Hezbollah to put forth a viable plan for the gradual return of these Syrian refugees one that would allow Lebanon to honor its commitment to maintain disassociation from the regional conflict and avoid further alienating itself from the Arab world.
Both Aoun and Hezbollah wish to use the refugees to serve a number of goals, which primarily include demonizing the refugees and the international community, and blame them for Lebanon’s collapsing economy. From their end both Aoun and Bassil, wish to divert Lebanese public attention from the series of corruption scandals and abysmal governance policies, which their term in office has so far yielded.
Hezbollah on the other hand wants everyone to believe that the Syrian crisis is over and its so-called resistance option has won the day. It is also expedient for Hezbollah and the Assad regime that many of these returning refugees will be conscripted in the Syrian army and driven to kill fellow Syrians who have yet admitted defeat.
The Lebanese have yet again failed to realize that towing this line, vis-à-vis the refugee can only exasperate matters further and impede the funds from the international community earmarked for projects that would help alleviate the economic burdens of the refugee crisis.
Hezbollah and its allies are trying to pass the insignificant organized refugee return coordinated by the Lebanese General Security as an end to all of Lebanon’s predicaments. However, a real end to Lebanon’s plight can only start after Hezbollah and their Iranian patrons decide to stop their sinister plans in the region and allow the Lebanese state to stand on its feet, an unlikely scenario that would be beneficial to all sides involved.
At the end of the day, Nasrallah can vow to return the Syrian refugees but his undertaking, like his pledge to liberate Palestine, is only for dramatic effect.
Makram Rabah is a lecturer at the American University of Beirut, Department of History. He is the author of A Campus at War: Student Politics at the American University of Beirut, 1967-1975. He tweets @makramrabah.
Israeli missiles ‘target Hezbollah depots’ in vicinity of Damascus AirportSyrian state media said early Tuesday that two Israeli missiles struck near Damascus International Airport, without adding any details. In a report in ... Middle East
Sanctions on Hezbollah a reminder of what may unfold for LebanonThe recent Lebanese parliamentary elections was not merely an occasion for selecting parliamentary representatives as it also underscored the ... Middle East
Nasrallah: Even the whole world cannot evict Hezbollah from SyriaLebanon’s Iran-backed Hezbollah will remain in Syria as long as Syrian President Bashar al-Assad wants it there, the group’s leader said ... Middle East
Will Hariri’s next cabinet include Hezbollah members?I’ve previously written an article here about Hezbollah that sips at the heart of the Lebanese state. Today, Hezbollah is a blacklisted ... Middle East