Iran’s risky choice of a U.N. ambassador, was it worth it?

Iran’s choice for its next ambassador to the United Nations in New York surprised the U.S. government

Camelia Entekhabi-Fard

Published: Updated:

Iran’s choice for its next ambassador to the United Nations in New York surprised the U.S. government. The nomination of Hamid Aboutalebi, a high-profile Iranian diplomat and advisor to President Hassan Rowhani, caused controversy recently because of his involvement with the student group, the Muslim Students Following the Imam’s Line, behind the 1979 hostage crisis at the U.S. embassy in Tehran. This involvement caused American officials to label his nomination as “not viable.”

That hostage crisis is still one of the most sensitive issues between the two countries. Iran has never apologized and relations between the U.S. and the Islamic Republic have never been great, but through great efforts in recent months, the two sides have been able to break the ice and improve relations. The historic phone call between Obama and Rowhani last September, when Rowhani was in New York to attend the U.N. General Assembly, was a great achievement for their two countries. Equally, the U.S. acceptance of Iran’s right to enrich uranium on a small scale as part of the P5+1 negotiations is a great achievement—one that could end the long running standoff between the U.S. and Iran over the latter’s nuclear program within only a few weeks.

But while Iran’s foreign minister, former U.N. ambassador Mohammad Javad Zarif, was busy last week with the Vienna nuclear talks aimed at securing a final agreement, this issue with the new U.N. ambassador provoked renewed tensions. Members of the U.S. Congress were aggrieved by the choice because of the sensitivities that still surround the hostage-taking in 1979, especially in light of their ongoing concerns about President Obama’s decision to improve relations with Tehran.

Point of contention

While officials in Tehran adamantly defended Aboutalebi’s nomination, both the Senate and the House unanimously passed a bill that would ban officials from entering the United States if they were involved in spying or terrorist activities against the country. Of course, Obama still has to sign the bill—and it has arrived on his desk not long after he went head-to-head with Congress over their attempt to pass a new round of sanctions against Iran contrary to the interim nuclear deal reached last fall. President Obama had to threaten to use his veto on any such sanctions bill, even though its mere passage through the House and the Senate would jeopardize his diplomatic efforts to resolve the nuclear issue.

Given the domestic political situation in America the decision to nominate Hamid Aboutalebi was unwise

Camelia Entekhabi-Fard

In its role as host of the U.N. headquarters, the U.S. is supposed to issue visas to anyone invited to or working at the U.N.. But there have been cases in the past where the U.S. denied entry to groups or people trying to go to the United Nations—including to members of former Iranian delegations attending the General Assembly.

Risking provocation

Although the ambassador has denied having any direct involvement in the hostage crisis, given the domestic political situation in America the decision to nominate Aboutalebi was unwise. Zarif has described the latest round of talks in Vienna as “important and critical”—so why did he risk provoking the United States with this nomination and why has he continued to defend it?

Was it really necessary for Iran to nominate a person with such a sensitive past, when it could hit another sore spot in Iran–U.S. relations at such a sensitive time?

Since the U.S. has said it will not permit Aboutalebi entry into the United States, Iran has the right to bring a complaint to the international court. But even if he is eventually allowed to go to New York, the new ambassador couldn’t possibly be in a position to fulfill his duties after all this media coverage.

This article was first published in Asharq al-Awsat on April 12, 2014.

Camelia Entekhabi-Fard is a journalist, news commentator and writer who grew up during the Iranian Revolution and wrote for leading reformist newspapers. She is also the author of Camelia: Save Yourself by Telling the Truth - A Memoir of Iran. She lives in New York City and Dubai. She can be found on Twitter: @CameliaFard

Disclaimer: Views expressed by writers in this section are their own and do not reflect Al Arabiya English's point-of-view.