Qatar’s ‘Small State Syndrome’
Doha is in fact still ruled by the old guard and Sheikh Tamim doesn’t intend to introduce any changes to his country’s controversial foreign policy
In psychology, the term “Napoleon complex” or “short man syndrome” usually refers to men of short stature who are characterized by overly-aggressive or domineering social behavior. It is believed that the behavior of these men is compensatory for their stature.
Most of us probably know people who suffer from this condition; however, upon monitoring the behavior of states like Qatar, one really wonders whether the same theory could possibly apply to nations as well as humans.
Qatar is a relatively small country geographically, it only gained its independence in 1971 and in a matter of only a few decades, saw itself transform from one of the region’s poorest nations to one of the world’s richest countries.
However, along with economic prosperity, many political analysts argue that over the years, Qatar has also developed an almost-Messianic obsession with “having a role.”
Begging to differ
Indeed, in the name of standing-out and in hope of being recognized as a global player, Qatar regularly made highly-controversial decisions when it came to its foreign policy.
Unfortunately, it was neighboring and fellow Gulf countries, particularly Saudi Arabia, that were often affected by these unjustifiably harmful decisions.
As such, Saudi Arabia’s recent announcement, that it (along with fellow GCC countries Bahrain and the UAE) would recall their ambassadors to Doha, was quite understandable; though it could be argued that this measure is unlikely to be effective in ultimately curing Qatar from what seems to be a severe case of “Small State Syndrome.”
On the other hand, what certainly wasn’t understandable was Doha’s response to the joint statement. Indeed, Qatar claimed it was “surprised” by the decision and also claimed that the rift with its neighbors was over “issues external to the Gulf Cooperation Council.”
However, the least that could be said about Qatar’s response is that it is hard to believe, particularly when several reports have attributed the decision to Doha’s consistent interference in the internal affairs of its fellow GCC countries.
A controversial foreign policy
Serious questions began emerging about Qatar’s foreign policy during the reign of Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa al-Thani (1995 – 2013). Until this day, many decisions made during that era continue to puzzle analysts.
For example, Qatar supported the pro-Iranian militant group Hezbollah, and continued to do so even after the assassination of (the Saudi-backed) former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafiq Hariri (which Hezbollah is now officially accused of carrying out) as well as after the Shiite group’s armed-takeover of Beirut in 2008.
Doha has also infamously backed President Assad of Syria up until the 2011 Syrian revolution against him. In the period that followed Hariri’s assassination, Qatar invested heavily in salvaging Assad’s tarnished image and reportedly assisted in reducing the international pressure on his regime through coordinated efforts with former French president Nicolas Sarkozy.
Qatar only turned against Assad after his brutal retaliation to the 2011 revolution against him, however, when Saudi Arabia took the lead in supporting the Syrian opposition, it is believed that Qatar insisted on supporting extreme Islamist fighters such as Jabhat al-Nusra, against Saudi advice, and also sought to undermine Syrian National Coalition figures that were not loyal to or pre-approved by Doha.
Saudi Arabia obtained audio recordings containing a conversation among top Qatari leaders discussing supporting an attempt to overthrow the Saudi monarchyFaisal J. Abbas
Furthermore and for nearly a decade, Qatar also supported Muammar Qaddafi, Libya’s controversial dictator, who among many things, was accused of plotting to assassinate Saudi Arabia’s King Abdullah.
Senior sources in Riyadh also say that following the toppling of Qaddafi in 2011, Saudi Arabia obtained audio recordings containing a conversation among top Qatari leaders discussing supporting an attempt to overthrow the Saudi monarchy. Unconfirmed reports hint that this audio recording was of Qatar’s former Emir Sheikh Hamad and former Foreign Minister Sheikh Hamad bin Jassim.
This of course wouldn’t be out of context if we also consider Qatar’s role in Yemen, where money was being reportedly paid to members of the al-Ahmar clan and pro-Brotherhood groups and where Houthis continue to be a source of instability to both Yemen itself and Saudi Arabia’s crucial southern border.
Qatar also continues to support the Muslim Brotherhood (which Saudi Arabia has recently officially labeled a terrorist organization). Just a few weeks ago, Doha’s support of the Brotherhood also became grounds of an official complaint by the UAE, which has been fighting the formation of Brotherhood cells on its lands.
Like father, like son
Doha is in fact still ruled by the old guard and Sheikh Tamim doesn’t intend to introduce any changes to his country’s controversial foreign policyFaisal J. Abbas
Indeed, that was at least the feeling following Sheikh Tamim’s first visit to Riyadh last August. Sheikh Tamim then returned to Riyadh in November and signed an accord with King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia. According to reports, the agreement included three items:
1- Cutting off all GCC ties with the Muslim Brotherhood
2- Ending broadcast privileges of Egyptian Scholar Yusef al-Qaradawi
3- Restricting movement of Iranian operatives within the GCC region.
However, despite the same terms being agreed again during the GCC’s Kuwait Summit in December, Qatar has failed to deliver on all three items. This has led many to believe that Doha is in fact still ruled by the old guard and that Sheikh Tamim doesn’t intend to introduce any changes to his country’s controversial foreign policy.
If this is the case, then one has every right to ask: with friends like Qatar, who needs enemies?
Faisal J. Abbas is the Editor-in-Chief of Al Arabiya English, he is a renowned blogger and an award-winning journalist who is working on an upcoming book on Arab Media. Faisal covered the Middle East extensively working for Future Television of Lebanon and both Al-Hayat and Asharq Al-Awsat pan-Arab dailies. He blogs for The Huffington Post since 2008, a recipient of many media awards and a member of the British Society of Authors, National Union of Journalists, the John Adams Society as well as an associate member of the Cambridge Union Society. He can be reached on @FaisalJAbbas on Twitter.
Egypt ‘will not’ send envoy back to DohaCairo has emboldened its stance against Qatar while the spat within the Gulf continues Middle East
After Qatar dispute, can we salvage a fragmented GCC?The Saudi, Emirati, and Bahraini decision to withdraw their ambassadors from Qatar doesn’t come as a surprise Middle East
Source: Qatar will ‘not let go’ of its foreign policyA source close to the Qatari government suggested Qatar will not bow to demands from three Gulf states to alter its foreign policy Middle East
Frustration with Qatar adds to GCC security disputeThe withdrawal of Gulf ambassadors from Doha could pose a grave challenge to the leadership of the Qatari emir Analysis
Qatar’s issues have been ongoing for 20 yearsQatar allied with Saudi Arabia’s rivals: Iran, Syria and Hezbollah Opinion
Gulf’s rift over Qatar may slow investmentDiplomatic split with Saudi Arabia, UAE and Bahrain may disrupt billions of dollars of investment in the region Economy
Saudi, Bahrain, UAE recall envoys to QatarGulf trio say the move was taken to 'to protect their security and stability of GCC states' Middle East
Kuwait’s emir could heal Gulf rift with Qatar, parliament speaker saysThe emir and his officials tried to soothe tensions between Gulf states in recent months Profiles
Gulf trio pull Qatar ambassadors - why now?The GCC states see Doha returning to its old tricks of pursuing policies unilaterally and outside of a GCC framework Middle East